The Indian compact SUV market has witnessed significant evolution, with two distinctive players commanding attention: the Mahindra Thar ROXX and the Maruti Suzuki Jimny. Both vehicles cater to enthusiasts seeking authentic off-road capabilities wrapped in urban practicality. However, they approach this challenge from fundamentally different philosophies. Understanding which SUV delivers better value depends on your priorities, lifestyle, and budget constraints.
Engine Performance and Power Dynamics
The performance gap between these two vehicles is substantial and immediately noticeable on the road. The Thar ROXX dominates this category with its turbocharged powertrains. The base petrol model produces 160 bhp and 330 Nm of torque from a 2.0-liter engine, while the diesel variant generates an impressive 172 bhp and 370 Nm of torque from a 2.2-liter engine. In contrast, the Jimny relies on a naturally aspirated 1.5-liter petrol engine producing just 103 bhp and 134.2 Nm of torque.
On the highway, the Thar ROXX’s superior performance is evident. Cruising effortlessly at triple-digit speeds and executing overtakes with confidence, the Thar ROXX delivers what modern buyers expect from a contemporary SUV. The Jimny, conversely, feels underwhelming on expressways, requiring higher revs to maintain highway speeds and demanding more frequent fuel stops due to its modest performance characteristics and 40-liter fuel tank capacity.
Read Also – Mahindra Scorpio N vs XUV700 Comparison
Pricing and Variant Accessibility
Both vehicles start at nearly identical price points, with the Thar ROXX commencing at ₹12.25 lakh and the Jimny at ₹12.31 lakh for base petrol variants. However, their variant progression tells different stories. The Thar ROXX offers 18 different variants spanning multiple engine options, transmission types, and drive configurations, extending up to ₹22.06 lakh for the top diesel automatic 4WD model.
The Jimny, meanwhile, offers more limited choices with just two variants—Zeta and Alpha—available in manual and automatic transmissions, with prices capping at ₹14.45 lakh for the fully-loaded automatic variant. This broader range in the Thar ROXX makes it accessible to different customer segments, from budget-conscious buyers to those seeking premium features and advanced technology.
Interior Space and Practicality
The Thar ROXX addresses what many considered the original Thar’s biggest limitation: practicality for family use. With five comfortable seats and a spacious 447-liter boot, the Thar ROXX comfortably accommodates families on extended journeys. The cabin showcases premium touches including a 10.25-inch touchscreen, Harman Kardon audio system, panoramic sunroof, ventilated front seats, and ADAS technology across multiple variants.
The Jimny is a fundamentally different proposition. Its compact four-seat cabin and 211-liter boot reflect its original design as a minimalist off-roader. Practicality concerns include the absence of bottle holders, missing seat-back pockets, and limited storage solutions. For daily family use, the Jimny’s trade-offs become apparent. However, its cozy, minimalist interior appeals to purists who view feature-laden cabins as unnecessary additions to a purpose-built off-roader.
Fuel Efficiency Comparison
The Jimny edges ahead in fuel economy metrics. With claimed efficiency figures ranging from 16.39 to 16.94 kmpl depending on transmission type, the Jimny demonstrates superior efficiency befitting its smaller engine and lighter weight. Real-world performance shows the Jimny returning approximately 11-12 kmpl in city driving and 15-16 kmpl on highways.
The Thar ROXX, despite its diesel option delivering 15.2 kmpl, consumes significantly more fuel in petrol form—managing around 12.4 kmpl in combined driving. Real-world data suggests city figures dropping to 10-11 kmpl for diesel variants. For high-mileage drivers, this efficiency gap translates into meaningful cost differences annually.
Safety Features and Ratings
Safety credentials reveal contrasting philosophies. The Thar ROXX achieved an impressive 5-star Bharat NCAP rating, making it one of India’s safest SUVs across all variants. The vehicle features six airbags, electronic stability control, ABS with EBD, and advanced ADAS systems including 360-degree cameras.
The Jimny received a 3-star Global NCAP rating, providing adequate but less impressive safety coverage. It includes six airbags, traction control, and electronic stability control, though it lacks the comprehensive ADAS suite found in its competitor. For safety-conscious families, the Thar ROXX’s superior rating justifies selection.
Off-Road Capabilities and Driving Experience
Both vehicles deliver legitimate off-road credentials, but with different strengths. The Jimny’s lighter weight and compact dimensions excel on tight, technical trails where maneuverability trumps power. Its 210mm ground clearance, combined with 36-degree approach and 46-degree departure angles, handles challenging terrain gracefully.
The Thar ROXX, while substantially larger, surprisingly delivers superior on-road dynamics. Its composed handling, strong brake bite, and highway capability make it more versatile for mixed usage. Highway comfort remains noticeably better due to improved suspension tuning, though the rear seats can feel bouncy on severely deteriorated roads. The 4WD diesel variant offers true expedition-ready capability, though this comes at a substantial price premium.
Maintenance and Service Network
The Jimny carries Maruti Suzuki’s formidable service advantage. With India’s largest after-sales network, finding service centers and qualified technicians proves effortless. Maintenance costs remain moderate around ₹2,500 per service, ensuring long-term ownership economical.
The Thar ROXX, while increasingly accessible, still relies on Mahindra’s developing service infrastructure. Regular servicing costs between ₹4,000-₹6,000, with five-year maintenance projected at approximately ₹17,562. Thar ROXX ownership remains straightforward, though Jimny’s established network provides additional convenience and potential savings in independent repair scenarios.
Final Verdict
Choose the Thar ROXX if you prioritize space, features, on-road performance, and safety ratings. Its superior power delivery, practical cabin, and comprehensive technology make it ideal for buyers viewing the SUV as their primary family vehicle with off-road capability as a bonus.
Choose the Jimny if you’re a budget-conscious off-roading enthusiast who values minimalism, fuel efficiency, and proven reliability. Its authentic off-roader character and exceptional service network suit buyers seeking a straightforward, dependable adventure partner.
Both vehicles deliver genuine value, but in different contexts. The Thar ROXX offers comprehensive versatility for modern families seeking contemporary features alongside off-road capability. The Jimny remains a purposeful, efficient alternative for those unwilling to compromise their off-roading philosophy for daily practicality. Neither choice disappoints—your ideal selection hinges upon recognizing which vehicle aligns with your specific lifestyle priorities.